Bien Logo

Twenty Women, One Man: What Competition Dating Quietly Does to Your Self-Worth

Mira Calloway4 min read
Share:
Twenty Women, One Man: What Competition Dating Quietly Does to Your Self-Worth — Relationship
In this article

There is a reason the format never goes out of style: a room full of women, one man deciding, and the delicious tension of who gets to stay. Another version of it is trending right now, and the group chats are already busy. I watch these shows too — but I've spent enough years listening to women talk about their love lives to know that the format doesn't stay on the screen. It seeps into how we behave on a first date, how we read a slow reply, how we quietly rank ourselves against a woman we've never met.

The problem isn't the entertainment. It's the underlying story: that love is a scarce prize awarded to the woman who performs best. Once you've absorbed that story, ordinary dating starts to feel like a callback you might not get.

The audition mindset, and how it shows up on a Tuesday

You don't need a television crew to be auditioning. It looks like rehearsing your anecdotes in the shower before dinner. It looks like editing your opinions down to the ones you think he'll find easy. It looks like agreeing you love hiking when you have never willingly walked up a hill. It looks like checking whether he has been active on the app since you last spoke, then deciding what that means about you.

The tell is a physical one. In an audition you are monitoring yourself from the outside — how do I sound, how do I look from that angle, am I being too much. In a genuine conversation your attention is pointed outward, at him: is he kind to the waiter, does he ask me anything, do I actually like the way he talks about his mother. If you leave a date knowing how you performed but not what you thought of him, you were auditioning.

Related reads

The Man Who Never Quite Arrives: Why Distance Still Gets Mistaken for Depth — Love

The Man Who Never Quite Arrives: Why Distance Still Gets Mistaken for Depth

We're still writing the withholding man as the interesting one. Here's how the pattern feels from the inside, and the unglamorous questions that break its spell.

Mira Calloway•
Dating Again After a Long Relationship: Surviving the First Month — Love

Dating Again After a Long Relationship: Surviving the First Month

The hardest part is rarely the dates themselves — it is the strange, exposing weeks around them. A gentle guide to starting again when the last time you did this, nobody had a smartphone.

Mira Calloway•
Together for Years, Never Married: The Conversations That Do the Work a Wedding Doesn't — Relationship

Together for Years, Never Married: The Conversations That Do the Work a Wedding Doesn't

A long partnership without a wedding isn't a lesser version of commitment — but it does ask you to be explicit about things a ceremony quietly assumes.

Mira Calloway•
The Friend Who Remembers It Differently — Relationship

The Friend Who Remembers It Differently

Two women can live through the same decade and come away with two different stories about it. Here's what to do when a friend's version of your shared past doesn't match yours.

Elise Navarro•
The Zodiac Signs Who Apologise Well — and the Ones Who Need a Few Days First — Esotericism

The Zodiac Signs Who Apologise Well — and the Ones Who Need a Few Days First

Some people say sorry within the hour and mean it. Others go quiet, tidy the kitchen furiously, and arrive three days later with the right words. Astrology has a language for both — and it can make autumn's small repairs much easier.

Elise Navarro•
When You Find Something in Your Teenager's Room That You Weren't Looking For — Family

When You Find Something in Your Teenager's Room That You Weren't Looking For

A story about a mother discovering a stash in her daughter's wardrobe has been doing the rounds again. Here's how to handle the first hour — and the conversation that follows.

Lena Hartley•