If you’ve just finished watching Anything But That Season 2 and found yourself ready to hit the “next episode” button right away, don’t worry—you’re not alone. This romantic comedy, inspired by Erin Foster’s own life, quickly won over hearts. Noah, the charming rabbi, and Joanne, the free-spirited podcaster, make every moment a joy with their unexpected romantic adventures, keeping viewers hooked on their journey.
Heads up: This text contains spoilers from Season 2!
Since its debut, the show has built a huge fanbase, and Season 2, already boasting impressive viewership, delivered an emotional rollercoaster: breakups, makeups, family drama, and redefined friendships. The great news? This beloved series is almost certainly continuing.
Season 3 Is Already in the Works
Netflix officially announced that Season 3 will arrive in 2026. Kristen Bell, who plays Joanne, revealed that the writers are hard at work on the new season—according to People.
The upcoming season looks promising, especially since Season 2 left many questions open: Will Joanne really convert to Judaism? Or might that become less important to Noah? How will their relationship evolve after the poolside drama? Will they move in together? And what about the other characters whose lives took big turns?
What to Expect in the New Season?
After Season 1’s finale, Noah and Joanne faced fresh relationship challenges. Though they briefly parted ways at the end of Season 2, their reunion hints that Season 3 will explore how they truly find their rhythm together.
Meanwhile, Joanne’s brother Morgan and Noah’s brother Sasha have also experienced major life changes: breakups, fresh starts, and evolving friendships all promise exciting new storylines.
Alongside Noah and Joanne’s journey, many are eager to see how Morgan, Sasha, and Esther’s stories unfold. Will Morgan and Sasha stay friends or fall for each other? Will Esther try to reconnect with Sasha or finally close that chapter? The possibilities feel endless, and the cast is just as excited to explore new twists with their characters.
Who’s Likely to Return on Screen?
Leads Adam Brody and Kristen Bell are expected to reprise their roles as Noah and Joanne, with supporting cast members like Justine Lupe, Jackie Tohn, and Timothy Simons almost certainly returning. The creators haven’t ruled out surprise cameos from Erin Foster and her sister Sara Foster, who also serves as a producer.
Justine Lupe, who plays Morgan, is especially excited about the characters’ futures. While romance remains central, she believes there’s room for the characters’ wild, funny friendship adventures too: unexpected pairings, hilarious misunderstandings, and city escapades will keep the story vibrant.
Where to Catch Up on Previous Seasons?
Both seasons are fully available on Netflix, so if you missed any episodes, it’s easy to catch up.
Or, of course, you can rewatch your favorite moments—the laughter-filled and thought-provoking scenes alike—before the new season drops.
Though details about Season 3 remain under wraps, it’s clear this heartwarming series still has plenty of excitement in store for us.
