Bien Logo

The Two Voices in Your Head: Making Peace With Wanting Opposite Things

Mira Calloway4 min read
Share:
The Two Voices in Your Head: Making Peace With Wanting Opposite Things — Mind & soul

Give both sides a fair hearing

A practical exercise I come back to often: take a sheet of paper, divide it in two, and write each side's case in the first person. Not pros and cons — actual voices. "I want to go because I've been shrinking here for three years." "I want to stay because my mother is twenty minutes away and she's getting older."

Something shifts when both positions are written out with equal dignity. You stop hearing one as the sensible adult and the other as the saboteur. Very often the quieter side isn't arguing against the decision at all — it's asking for a condition. It doesn't say no to the move; it says, not without a plan for Mum. That's negotiable. Whereas a vague sense of dread is not.

Then ask each side the same question: what are you afraid will happen if I don't listen to you? The answers are usually more specific, and more addressable, than the surface disagreement suggested.

In relationships, both people can be right

The same principle saves an enormous amount of unnecessary conflict between couples. Wanting closeness and wanting autonomy are not opposing personality types assigned one per household. Both people usually contain both, in different proportions, on different days.

Related reads

The Last Thing She Said: How Friendships End, and Why the Final Words Stay — Relationship

The Last Thing She Said: How Friendships End, and Why the Final Words Stay

Friendships rarely end with a conversation — but when they do, the parting line can lodge in you for years. Here's why it lands so hard, and what to do with it.

Mira Calloway•
Everyone's an Expert on Someone Else's Marriage — What That Habit Does to Yours — Relationship

Everyone's an Expert on Someone Else's Marriage — What That Habit Does to Yours

A trending conversation about whether a famous couple's dynamic is loving or controlling has the internet playing therapist again. Here's what clip-based diagnosis gets wrong — and how to think about the relationships you can actually see.

Mira Calloway•
The Word "Selfish" Is Doing Too Much Work in Your Head — Mind & soul

The Word "Selfish" Is Doing Too Much Work in Your Head

Most women who worry about being selfish are nowhere near it. Here is how to tell self-respect from self-indulgence — and what actually changes when you stop apologising for having needs.

Mira Calloway•
The Friend Who Remembers It Differently — Relationship

The Friend Who Remembers It Differently

Two women can live through the same decade and come away with two different stories about it. Here's what to do when a friend's version of your shared past doesn't match yours.

Elise Navarro•
Four Zodiac Signs Whose "I'm Fine" Almost Never Means Fine — Esotericism

Four Zodiac Signs Whose "I'm Fine" Almost Never Means Fine

Some people fall apart loudly. These four do it behind a closed door, with a cup of tea and a convincing smile. Here's how to recognise it — and how to get in.

Elise Navarro•
Four Zodiac Signs Who Quietly Dread the Festive Season — and What Each One Needs — Esotericism

Four Zodiac Signs Who Quietly Dread the Festive Season — and What Each One Needs

Not everyone is counting down to December. Four signs tend to feel the weight of the season before it even arrives — for four completely different reasons.

Elise Navarro•