Bien Logo

When "I'm struggling financially" is just empty solidarity. Can we hold a friend accountable for their money situation?

Barbara Lee3 min read
Share:
When "I'm struggling financially" is just empty solidarity. Can we hold a friend accountable for their money situation? — Lifestyle

Chances are, I’m not alone in having money as a regular topic in my friend group. More precisely: the lack of it. Thankfully, these aren’t dramatic talks about survival, but the typical sighs of urban middle-class folks in their twenties, thirties, and forties. We have steady incomes, we work, pay bills, and still find some fun money. But like most, there’s always something each month we say, “this just can’t fit in right now.”

Someone suggests meeting at their place because coffee shops feel like a luxury. Another complains about the gas bill. We share a bag we’ve been eyeing with a note: “once I save up for it.” These are everyday, human moments—part complaint, part self-aware humor. I think they’re healthy too—we openly pay attention to money, prioritize, and save.

But there’s a friend who doesn’t just join these talks—she one-ups everyone. It’s like financial struggle is a competition, and the winner is the one who suffers the most. She talks about her money troubles with such passion and drama that sometimes I feel awkward. All while hanging up her newest fur coat in my hallway, arriving in her trendy new car—from that downtown apartment she rents on one of the priciest streets, which is roughly twice the size of mine.

Young woman lying on a pile of money

It’s not about envy. Really, it’s not. It’s more about feeling uncomfortable.

Because what happens then?

We sit there while she talks about tightening her belt, even though her coat might cost more than my three months of groceries.

And I don’t know how to respond. Should I laugh? Stay silent? Ask questions? Or just nod with a sympathetic face?

Money is a sensitive topic

These moments are tricky because money is inherently sensitive. We don’t see each other’s bank accounts. We don’t know everyone’s obligations, family background, or support system. Someone with a high income might still feel insecure—maybe they spend more, have loans, or maintain a higher lifestyle. The phrase “I’m struggling financially” is relative.

But when the contrast is this obvious, it’s no longer just relative. It becomes a role.

And maybe that’s what really bothers me. It’s not that she has more money. It’s that she acts like we’re in the same boat when we’re not. Like she’s competing in hardship. Like she needs to be the one in the worst spot—even if everything around her clearly says otherwise.

That makes me wonder: what does she want from this? Sympathy? Connection? To not stand out? Or is her lifestyle so normal to her that she truly feels squeezed if she only buys two coats in a season?

Woman in a fur coat

Here comes the tough part: when is it time to speak up?

Because at some point, it’s not just awkward—it creates tension. When someone says “can’t afford it” but shows up the next day with a new designer bag, it starts to feel less credible. And credibility is a foundation of friendship.

But calling it out is risky. What if I hurt their feelings? What if they get defensive? What if they really do carry burdens we don’t know about?

Burning dollar bills

Shame and insecurity around money can run deep—even for those who seem well off from the outside.

Maybe “calling out” isn’t the right phrase. It’s more about honest curiosity.

Maybe one day, in a private moment, I’ll ask: what exactly does she mean when she says she’s struggling financially? What does she feel she can’t afford, and what leaves her feeling lacking?

But I don’t know when that moment will come. Maybe it’s when staying silent hurts more than asking the uncomfortable question.

Related reads

My friend keeps planning expensive outings — here's how I finally told her I couldn't keep up — Lifestyle

My friend keeps planning expensive outings — here's how I finally told her I couldn't keep up

When a close friend keeps organizing pricey plans, saying no feels impossible. Here's how one honest conversation changed everything — without damaging the friendship.

Barbara Lee
Should I financially support my friend’s business too? — Lifestyle

Should I financially support my friend’s business too?

When my friend started her own business, I admired her courage. But as a friend, am I obliged to support her financially?

Barbara Lee
When It’s Annoying Because You Know They’ll Be There: Is Quitting Over an Annoying Colleague Really Worth It? — Lifestyle

When It’s Annoying Because You Know They’ll Be There: Is Quitting Over an Annoying Colleague Really Worth It?

Our work environment and colleagues shape our daily lives. But is it truly worth quitting because of a difficult coworker, or are there better ways to handle it?

Barbara Lee
Your most successful female colleague could be your greatest ally — here's how to motivate each other instead of competing — Lifestyle

Your most successful female colleague could be your greatest ally — here's how to motivate each other instead of competing

That confident, high-achieving woman at work doesn't have to be your rival. Here's what I learned when I stopped seeing her as competition — and started seeing her as an ally.

Isabella Reed
Joint finances or separate accounts? The money decision that can make or break your relationship — Lifestyle

Joint finances or separate accounts? The money decision that can make or break your relationship

Should couples share their finances or keep them separate? The answer might surprise you — and it could be the most important conversation you have together.

Isabella Reed
Financial anxiety is becoming an epidemic — and it's not just about being broke — Lifestyle

Financial anxiety is becoming an epidemic — and it's not just about being broke

From inflation to social media pressure, more people than ever are losing sleep over money — even those who seem financially stable. Here's why, and what helps.

Isabella Reed