When the first season of Anything But This dropped in September 2024, few expected it to be so heartfelt. Even fewer might have guessed how perfectly ironic the title would become—because honestly, it feels like everyone wants exactly this. A special story where humor, faith, family, and love intertwine with honesty and warmth.
The New Season Arrives This Fall
Given the success of Anything But This, it’s no surprise a new season was already filmed. Jackie Tohn, who plays Esther, shared the exciting news on Instagram on May 12—and the wait won’t be long! The new season premieres on Netflix on October 23, bringing fresh faces, new twists, second chances, and even more lovable chaos.
Romance Is Still Guaranteed
If you haven’t caught the first season yet, here’s a quick taste: the story centers on Joanne (Kristen Bell), a non-religious, free-spirited podcaster, and Noah (Adam Brody), a recently single rabbi. Their love story unfolds at a dinner party. It’s partly inspired by real life—one of the creators, Erin Foster, experienced a similar journey and eventually embraced Judaism.
The first season ended with Joanne considering conversion—a deeply personal choice that’s also key to Noah’s growth as a rabbi. Despite doubts from those around them and even themselves, Joanne and Noah stayed together. Expect more of the same in season two; behind-the-scenes photos show them cuddled up on a couch, so the romance is definitely alive and well.
Meet the New Faces of Season 2
Season 2 introduces several new characters, including some familiar names that promise plenty of drama and laughs. The most exciting new addition might be Leighton Meester as Abby, Joanne’s high school rival turned momfluencer, bringing lots of comedic moments. Bonus: Leighton Meester is married to Adam Brody in real life, which is sure to make their scenes even more fun.
Miles Fowler plays Lenny, Noah’s basketball teammate, who’s expected to get closer to Joanne’s sister Morgan (Justin Lupe). Alex Karpovsky appears as “Big Noah,” a confident rabbi, while Arian Moayed joins as Dr. Andy, a therapist who might help Morgan find more than just healing.
Returning Favorites from the Original Cast
Of course, the main cast—Kristen Bell, Adam Brody, Justine Lupe, and Timothy Simons—are back, making the continuation feel just right. Jackie Tohn’s Esther steps up to a regular role this season. Plus, Stephanie Faracy, Michael Hitchcock, Tovah Feldshuh, Paul Ben-Victor, Emily Arlook, Sherry Cola, and Shiloh Berman all return.
When a show can make you laugh, think, and feel deeply all at once, you know it’s something special. If witty banter, heartfelt twists, and humor born from cultural differences are your thing, then the October 23 premiere of Anything But This season two is a must-watch. Need another reason to mark your calendar? We don’t think so!
