Bien Logo

Is the Second Marriage Always Happier? Pros and Cons

Angela Price3 min read
Share:
Is the Second Marriage Always Happier? Pros and Cons — Wedding
In this article
premium_photo-1661322722415-b2fe93b23977.jpg
premium_photo-1661322722415-b2fe93b23977.jpg
premium_photo-1661432699523-ab9139c47669.jpg
premium_photo-1661432699523-ab9139c47669.jpg
premium_photo-1661432403711-3f7c27f329c1.jpg
premium_photo-1661432403711-3f7c27f329c1.jpg

Research shows that second marriages often face more challenges, with about 60% ending in divorce.

The Baggage

Both my new wife and I came into our second marriage carrying big baggage: the trauma of divorce, resentment towards our exes, and children from previous relationships. Plus, the disappointment of having once said “I do” believing it would last forever. We both tried hard, but it didn’t work out. I divorced for the second time and vowed never to marry again. It would be laughable if I promised “till death do us part” a third time in front of everyone.

Wiser Choices

Of course it’s happier! At least for me. When I married my first husband, we were 21 and clueless about life and living together. We were in love and naively thought that was enough — spoiler: it wasn’t. My second marriage happened after 30, when I was more mature and experienced, avoiding the mistakes I made the first time.

Failure

My second marriage happened because I wanted to show my ex-wife how quickly I moved on — so this new union had no real chance from the start. My poor wife tried, but I was still in love with my ex, who broke my heart by leaving me for my boss. It was a messy time, but the second divorce was easier since the marriage lasted less than a year, so there wasn’t much to fight over. Now I’m in love again and planning to propose — fingers crossed that “third time’s the charm.”

Speaking Up

My first marriage was full of unspoken feelings, arguments, sulking, and stubborn silence. In my second, I learned that communication is key, and that changed everything. My current wife and I don’t hide anything from each other; we openly share what hurts us and what we want, which makes our relationship thrive.

Out of the Frying Pan

After my first divorce, I thought I couldn’t face a bigger failure — but my second marriage was even tougher. It almost made me give up on marriage forever.

The Choice

I chose better the second time. My first husband and I had nothing in common beyond attraction, which isn’t enough for a good marriage. I’m a linguist who loves cozying up with a book; he’s a carpenter who always needs company. I love traveling; he won’t get on a plane. We realized our lifestyles clashed and couldn’t mesh. We’re still on good terms, and both found second spouses who share many of our traits.

Care and Effort

On our second try, we both understood marriage is hard work that only succeeds if both partners commit and put in effort. An American comedian once said marriage is like carrying a couch: one person can’t do it alone, but together it’s easy. I hesitated, but when I saw my partner was ready to “carry the couch” with me, I said yes — and never regretted it.

More Meaningful

With my first marriage, I didn’t really know what I was getting into. The second felt much more meaningful — my vows carried real weight this time.

Realistic Expectations

I entered my second marriage knowing no union is perfect. We accept each other’s flaws, and that’s worked for eight years now. I also appreciate the relationship more and am grateful for my husband. With my first husband, we took each other for granted — a fatal mistake.

Related reads

Why marriages go cold — and it's not just the woman's fault — Wedding

Why marriages go cold — and it's not just the woman's fault

Many couples feel the emotional warmth fade after the wedding. But who's really responsible — and what does that signed paper actually change in us?

Elizabeth Carter
Marriage is not ownership: Why I'm keeping my name after the wedding — Family

Marriage is not ownership: Why I'm keeping my name after the wedding

I knew from a young age I wouldn't leave my name at the altar. Here's why keeping it isn't a rejection of marriage — it's an act of self-respect.

Elizabeth Carter
From "I'll Never Marry" to Saying Yes: What Finally Changed My Mind About Marriage — Wedding

From "I'll Never Marry" to Saying Yes: What Finally Changed My Mind About Marriage

I spent years convinced marriage was just a piece of paper. Then life knocked me flat — and I realized what "I do" actually means when it truly matters.

Elizabeth Carter
7 things wedding guests do that silently drive the couple crazy — Wedding

7 things wedding guests do that silently drive the couple crazy

Being a great wedding guest takes more than showing up with a gift. Avoid these 7 common mistakes and make the day truly unforgettable — for all the right reasons.

Zelie O.
They Said It Was My Duty: Real Stories of Sexual Coercion in Relationships — Lifestyle

They Said It Was My Duty: Real Stories of Sexual Coercion in Relationships

These women share what it's really like when a partner uses guilt, rage, or emotional pressure to demand sex. Their stories are raw, painful — and more common than you'd think.

Angela Price
What his driving style reveals about him: real stories that said it all — Relationship

What his driving style reveals about him: real stories that said it all

From speeding to road rage, the way a man drives can tell you more about his character than months of dating. These real stories prove it.

Angela Price