Everyone has an opinion about roast potatoes and almost nobody has a consistent result. One week they come out craggy and golden; the next, from the same oven and the same bag of potatoes, they're smooth, pale and faintly waxy. It isn't luck. Four things decide the outcome, and once you know what they are you can repeat a good batch on purpose.
Choose a floury potato and cut it bigger than you think
A waxy potato holds its shape beautifully in a salad and resists everything you want from a roastie. You need a floury, high-starch variety — the sort that goes fluffy when baked and collapses slightly when mashed. If you're unsure, the supermarket's "roasting" label is a reasonable guide, and anything sold for baking usually behaves well.
Cut them into large, uneven chunks, roughly the size of a small plum, with at least one flat face where you can. Small pieces sound efficient but they dry out before the outside has crisped, and you lose the fluffy interior that makes the contrast worth having. Uneven edges are an advantage: every corner is a future crunch.
Parboil, then dry them out properly
This is the stage people rush. Start the potatoes in cold, well-salted water, bring to the boil and simmer until the outside is genuinely soft — a knife slides into the edges easily and the surfaces are just beginning to fray. Underboiled potatoes cannot crisp, because there's no softened starch on the outside to turn into a crust.
Drain them and leave them in the colander for a few minutes to steam off. Then put the lid on the empty pan, tip them back in and shake, hard enough to rough up the surfaces into a fluffy, floury coating. If you like, dust them with a spoonful of semolina or plain flour at this point. The goal is a potato that looks slightly fuzzy, not smooth and glossy.






