Bien Logo

When Someone Comments on Your Body, You Don't Owe Them the Backstory

Mira Calloway5 min read
Share:
When Someone Comments on Your Body, You Don't Owe Them the Backstory — Mind & soul
In this article

Somebody always notices first. You walk into a family gathering, or back into the office after a long absence, and before anyone asks how you slept or how the move went, there is a scan — quick, practised, usually delivered with a smile — followed by a sentence about your body. You've lost weight. You've filled out. You look tired. You look well, said in the particular tone that means something else. This week a widely shared exchange about a public figure defending herself against strangers' remarks reminded a lot of women that the same conversation happens at much smaller tables, with people who are supposed to love us.

What makes those moments so destabilising is not usually the comment. It's the split second afterwards, when you feel obliged to explain: the illness, the grief, the medication, the divorce, the perimenopause, the fact that you simply stopped caring about a certain kind of eating. You end up narrating your own body to someone who never earned that access.

Why the explanation trap is so hard to resist

Most of us were raised to answer questions. When somebody says "you've got so thin," it lands with the grammar of a question even when it isn't one, and silence feels rude. There is also a second pull: if the change came from something painful, part of you wants to correct the assumption. You don't want them thinking you did this on purpose. You don't want to be admired for a year that nearly broke you.

But explanations invite follow-ups. Give one detail and you get three more questions, then advice, then a story about their cousin. The kindest thing you can do for your own nervous system is to decide, before the event, that your body is not a topic you're workshopping today. That decision made in advance does more than any clever line, because it means you are not improvising while your heart rate climbs.

Related reads

Everyone's an Expert on Someone Else's Marriage — What That Habit Does to Yours — Relationship

Everyone's an Expert on Someone Else's Marriage — What That Habit Does to Yours

A trending conversation about whether a famous couple's dynamic is loving or controlling has the internet playing therapist again. Here's what clip-based diagnosis gets wrong — and how to think about the relationships you can actually see.

Mira Calloway•
The Word "Selfish" Is Doing Too Much Work in Your Head — Mind & soul

The Word "Selfish" Is Doing Too Much Work in Your Head

Most women who worry about being selfish are nowhere near it. Here is how to tell self-respect from self-indulgence — and what actually changes when you stop apologising for having needs.

Mira Calloway•
The Last Thing She Said: How Friendships End, and Why the Final Words Stay — Relationship

The Last Thing She Said: How Friendships End, and Why the Final Words Stay

Friendships rarely end with a conversation — but when they do, the parting line can lodge in you for years. Here's why it lands so hard, and what to do with it.

Mira Calloway•
The Friend Who Remembers It Differently — Relationship

The Friend Who Remembers It Differently

Two women can live through the same decade and come away with two different stories about it. Here's what to do when a friend's version of your shared past doesn't match yours.

Elise Navarro•
Five Zodiac Signs Who Say Yes When They Mean No — Esotericism

Five Zodiac Signs Who Say Yes When They Mean No

Some people agree instantly, then spend the next week quietly resenting it. Here are the signs most likely to over-commit — and the specific sentence each one needs in her back pocket.

Elise Navarro•
The Four Zodiac Signs Who Forgive Too Fast — and What It Quietly Costs Them — Esotericism

The Four Zodiac Signs Who Forgive Too Fast — and What It Quietly Costs Them

Some people are praised for how quickly they let things go. Astrology has names for them — and a gentle warning about the difference between forgiving someone and simply skipping the uncomfortable conversation.

Elise Navarro•