Bien Logo

When Someone Comments on Your Body, You Don't Owe Them the Backstory

Mira Calloway5 min read
Share:
When Someone Comments on Your Body, You Don't Owe Them the Backstory — Mind & soul

Short replies that close the subject without a scene

The most effective responses are unembarrassed, brief, and slightly boring. Boring is the point: there is nothing to grab onto. Try "I'd rather not talk about my body, but tell me about your summer." Or simply "Mm," followed by a question of your own. "That's a strange thing to say to someone" works when you have the energy for a small, calm confrontation. "I'm well, thank you" answers the concern underneath without conceding the topic.

If it's a colleague, keep it flat and pivot to work — "All fine, thanks. Did the revised deck go out?" If it's your mother, you may need to name the pattern rather than the incident: "I know you mean it warmly, but when we start with my weight I stop enjoying the visit. Can we not?" Say it once, in daylight, not in the middle of a flare-up. Then hold it. Most people adjust after two or three repetitions; the ones who don't are telling you something useful about themselves.

Being the person who doesn't comment

The other half of this is worth an honest look. Almost all of us have complimented somebody's weight loss without knowing what caused it, because we were taught that it's the safest kind of praise. It isn't. A woman recovering from an eating disorder hears applause for her illness. A woman on new medication hears that her value moved with the number. A woman who gained weight during a hard year hears the implied opposite.

Related reads

Everyone's an Expert on Someone Else's Marriage — What That Habit Does to Yours — Relationship

Everyone's an Expert on Someone Else's Marriage — What That Habit Does to Yours

A trending conversation about whether a famous couple's dynamic is loving or controlling has the internet playing therapist again. Here's what clip-based diagnosis gets wrong — and how to think about the relationships you can actually see.

Mira Calloway•
The Word "Selfish" Is Doing Too Much Work in Your Head — Mind & soul

The Word "Selfish" Is Doing Too Much Work in Your Head

Most women who worry about being selfish are nowhere near it. Here is how to tell self-respect from self-indulgence — and what actually changes when you stop apologising for having needs.

Mira Calloway•
The Last Thing She Said: How Friendships End, and Why the Final Words Stay — Relationship

The Last Thing She Said: How Friendships End, and Why the Final Words Stay

Friendships rarely end with a conversation — but when they do, the parting line can lodge in you for years. Here's why it lands so hard, and what to do with it.

Mira Calloway•
The Friend Who Remembers It Differently — Relationship

The Friend Who Remembers It Differently

Two women can live through the same decade and come away with two different stories about it. Here's what to do when a friend's version of your shared past doesn't match yours.

Elise Navarro•
Five Zodiac Signs Who Say Yes When They Mean No — Esotericism

Five Zodiac Signs Who Say Yes When They Mean No

Some people agree instantly, then spend the next week quietly resenting it. Here are the signs most likely to over-commit — and the specific sentence each one needs in her back pocket.

Elise Navarro•
The Four Zodiac Signs Who Forgive Too Fast — and What It Quietly Costs Them — Esotericism

The Four Zodiac Signs Who Forgive Too Fast — and What It Quietly Costs Them

Some people are praised for how quickly they let things go. Astrology has names for them — and a gentle warning about the difference between forgiving someone and simply skipping the uncomfortable conversation.

Elise Navarro•