Bien Logo

"Do I Really Deserve This?" – Why Do I Feel Guilty Even After Making a Good Decision?

Farkas Margaréta3 min read
Share:
"Do I Really Deserve This?" – Why Do I Feel Guilty Even After Making a Good Decision? — Lifestyle
In this article

A few months ago, I set my sights on a camera. This wasn’t an impulse buy. I spent weeks watching reviews, comparisons, and crunching numbers—how often I’d use it, if it was really worth it, and whether I truly needed it. It was one of those decisions you keep revisiting over and over again. When I finally bought it, joy was the first feeling. But that didn’t last long before another thought popped up: Was this really the right choice? At one point, I even wondered if I truly "deserved" it. It was a strange feeling because everything pointed to the decision being perfectly fine. I’d thought it through, could afford it, and genuinely felt happy. Yet, that little flicker of doubt was still there. And I’m pretty sure I’m not alone in feeling this way.

When the Second Guessing Starts After the Decision

We often think the hard part is making the decision. We weigh options, list pros and cons in our heads, compare possibilities. Once we decide, logic says the story should end there. But in reality, this is often when a new wave of doubt begins. We start rethinking our choice. Did I consider everything? Did I miss something? What if I’d picked the other option? The more energy we put into deciding, the easier it is to question it afterward.

Woman thinking with her phone in hand

The Hidden Side of Choices

Every decision has a less visible side—the other options we didn’t choose. When I decided to buy the camera, I let go of all the alternatives. I could have spent the money elsewhere, waited another year, or picked a cheaper model. These alternatives don’t just disappear. Our brain sometimes brings them back, as if double-checking: was this really the best choice? That’s when the strange feeling creeps in that maybe we got more than we deserved.

Abstract stair maze

The Trap of Overthinking

There comes a point when thinking stops helping and just goes in circles. Psychologists call this rumination—an endless loop of analyzing a decision without finding new answers.

At times like this, we’re not really searching for the real problem. We’re chasing the comforting feeling that we made the right choice.

The catch is, most decisions rarely come with 100% certainty.

Silhouette of a woman

The “Do I Deserve This?” Question

This feeling is especially interesting when the decision works in our favor. When we buy something we’ve wanted, when an opportunity turns out well, or when we finally choose something for ourselves. Sometimes a strange question pops up: Do I really deserve this? Often, it’s just that after long reflection, we made a choice that benefits us—and that alone doesn’t make it "wrong".

Young woman writing in a notebook

Maybe Doubt Is Part of Every Decision

We like to believe there’s a perfect decision—one after which we can relax completely, sure we did the right thing. But reality is much more human. Most decisions leave a little doubt behind. A tiny thought about what might have happened if we took a different path. Maybe it simply means the decision mattered to us. Not every good choice has to leave us feeling totally calm right away. Sometimes, just taking the step that felt best at the moment is enough.

Related reads

Is it OK to cancel plans sometimes? Here's what psychologists actually say — Health

Is it OK to cancel plans sometimes? Here's what psychologists actually say

You've known for days you should go out, but you keep making excuses. Is that a red flag or just self-care? Psychologists have a surprisingly reassuring answer.

Farkas Margaréta
Why we're obsessed with true crime — and what it's quietly doing to our minds — Lifestyle

Why we're obsessed with true crime — and what it's quietly doing to our minds

True crime has taken over our podcasts, shows and bookshelves. Here's what really draws us in — and how bingeing it can affect your mental health.

Farkas Margaréta
Why You Keep Dreaming About School Years Later — and What It Really Says About You — Lifestyle

Why You Keep Dreaming About School Years Later — and What It Really Says About You

You left school decades ago, so why does that anxious exam dream keep coming back? Psychology says it's not about your past — it's about your present.

Nyul Debóra
7 phrases confident women quietly repeat to themselves almost every day — Lifestyle

7 phrases confident women quietly repeat to themselves almost every day

Self-confidence isn't something you're born with — it's a skill you can build. These 7 everyday phrases can help you feel steadier and more sure of yourself.

Nyul Debóra
The Way You See Your Body? You Probably Learned It From Your Mother — Lifestyle

The Way You See Your Body? You Probably Learned It From Your Mother

The way you talk about your body may not be yours at all. Discover how your mother's relationship with her own body quietly shaped how you see yourself.

Farkas Margaréta
Why You Gossip More Than You Think — and Why Your Brain Loves It — Lifestyle

Why You Gossip More Than You Think — and Why Your Brain Loves It

Gossip isn't just a bad habit. Psychologists say it plays a vital social role, helping us build trust, protect ourselves, and keep our communities together.

Farkas Izabella