Bien Logo

“They Were Always the Golden Child” – 3 Signs Your Relationship with Your Sibling Is Toxic

Schuster Borka4 min read
Share:
“They Were Always the Golden Child” – 3 Signs Your Relationship with Your Sibling Is Toxic — Family
In this article

One of You Relies Too Much on the Other: The Responsible Sibling and the Eternal Child

One of You Relies Too Much on the Other: The Responsible Sibling and the Eternal Child
In this sibling dynamic, the Responsible one matures too early. They’re always dependable, disciplined, and practical. On the flip side, the Eternal Child is typically the opposite. They’re headstrong, follow their own will, driven by passion, and struggle with self-discipline.

The Eternal Child is often charming, spontaneous, and playful. They’re fun to be around but not always reliable partners. Essentially, they’re kids living in adult bodies, finding it hard to function as adults in the real world.

Usually, when there’s an Eternal Child in the family, there’s a Responsible sibling paired with them. Because of this dynamic, the Responsible sibling feels they can’t afford to be a disappointment like their sibling. They believe they have no choice but to follow the path set for them and become a successful, functioning member of society. The Responsible one does everything expected of them—but it’s not a free choice. They do it because full compliance was once demanded of them. They might have taken on the role of a depressed parent who made it clear they had no extra energy for parenting, or they might be overcompensating for a violent and unpredictable parent who would get angry if things weren’t perfect.

Jokes Always Come at One of Your Expense: The Bully and the Silent One

Jokes Always Come at One of Your Expense: The Bully and the Silent One
In a healthy environment, a parent disciplines their child if they speak disrespectfully or act aggressively. But some parents, due to their own attachment needs and trauma history, don’t do this. They deeply fear conflict and losing their children, so they do everything to please them. They avoid being the "bad cop" and don’t discipline the acting-out child. When a parent can’t enforce authority, children have to find their own boundaries—a nearly impossible task.

Sibling abuse creates a polarized dynamic between a Bully and a Silent Victim. For the Bully, escaping aggression—and even abuse—is no blessing. Kids need boundaries and often test if they exist. When the Bully can’t find these limits, which their parents should have set, the world feels chaotic and scary. The Bully is often a neglected, abused, or hurt child. Inside, they feel powerless and carry constant shame, but their only way to release pain is by hurting their siblings.

The Silent siblings have learned to stay quiet because they could never tell their story. They were threatened or believed no one would believe them. Their only choice was to disconnect and bury the trauma deep in their body and soul. Later in life, this trauma may show as chronic fatigue, physical pain, depression, or anxiety.

You’re Always Compared to Each Other: The Golden Child and the Black Sheep

You’re Always Compared to Each Other: The Golden Child and the Black Sheep
Though many deny it, parents often have a favorite child. When this becomes obvious, the Golden Child and Black Sheep dynamic takes shape. The family’s Black Sheep is the scapegoat, always portrayed as "bad" and never doing anything right. Through projection and projective identification as defense mechanisms, the family blames the scapegoat for all problems. The scapegoat is often pushed aside and blamed when things go wrong.

Because parents see the Golden Child as an extension of themselves, they won’t let the Black Sheep threaten their narrative. So when the scapegoat does something right, their achievements are ignored or dismissed. The Golden Child must always be the best at everything, and the Black Sheep is only recognized as long as the Golden Child’s shine remains unthreatened.

If the Black Sheep internalizes the role assigned by their family, they struggle with low self-esteem, carry toxic shame, and don’t believe they deserve happiness and success. Unconsciously, they may feel that if they achieve something, they’ll be attacked and criticized for it. So even as adults, they might sabotage themselves to avoid the expected attack.

But the Golden Child’s life isn’t all smooth sailing either: they carry their parents’ ambitions. While the Black Sheep is forced to be autonomous and find their own way, the Golden Child must merge with controlling parents. They’re subtly punished or threatened if they don’t follow the path set for them. Even as adults, they often feel they must "do the right thing" or appease their parents. They might struggle to be spontaneous or do anything outside the traditional path.

Additionally, the Golden Child may suffer from unconscious guilt, seeing their sibling treated unfairly but feeling powerless to help. Later in life, they might develop a "rescuer complex," drawn to vulnerable partners who need support.
FamilyLifestyle

Related reads

"My mother-in-law lost it when she realized she no longer had power over my husband" — real stories of men who finally drew the line — Family

"My mother-in-law lost it when she realized she no longer had power over my husband" — real stories of men who finally drew the line

In a healthy marriage, a wife comes first — but can men really stand up to their own mothers? These real stories show what it looks like when husbands finally do.

Szőke Angéla•
When Grandparents Cross the Line: "She Fed My 7-Month-Old Spicy Stew" — Family

When Grandparents Cross the Line: "She Fed My 7-Month-Old Spicy Stew"

Grandparents are irreplaceable — but what happens when their help turns into overriding your parenting decisions? Three moms share their stories.

Schuster Borka•
Always the family scapegoat? Your birth order might explain why — Family

Always the family scapegoat? Your birth order might explain why

Psychologists say your place in the sibling lineup shapes the family role you're handed — including who always gets blamed. Here's why it might be you.

Váradi Petra•
My parents stayed together for us. I wish they hadn't. — Family

My parents stayed together for us. I wish they hadn't.

As a child, I was told my parents stayed together for our sake. As an adult, I've come to see that decision very differently — and more honestly.

Schuster Borka•
"For years, I didn't enjoy being a mother — but I was too afraid to tell anyone" — Family

"For years, I didn't enjoy being a mother — but I was too afraid to tell anyone"

Social media sells a perfect version of motherhood. But for many women, the reality is far more complicated. Three mothers share what they were too afraid to say out loud.

Schuster Borka•
"My dad isn't my biological father" — the family secret my dying mother told me — Family

"My dad isn't my biological father" — the family secret my dying mother told me

On her deathbed, my mother confessed something that changed everything I thought I knew about myself — and the man who raised me.

Váradi Petra•