Then state the change and stop talking. The strong urge to over-explain, to justify, to soften it with five reasons is what usually reopens the negotiation. One sentence of reason is plenty. And if your partner and you disagree about whose family is being unreasonable, that conversation needs to happen between the two of you first — nothing hardens a boundary faster, or dissolves it faster, than which of you is standing where.
How do I ask for my key back without starting a row?
Give a practical reason that is not about the person, offer a replacement system, and deliver it in one short, warm sentence rather than a prepared speech. Something like: "We're changing how we do keys — there's a lockbox now for emergencies, so could I take the spare back when you're next over?" If they are hurt, acknowledge the feeling without reversing the decision: "I know it feels like a big deal, and I understand why — it isn't about you."
Is it unreasonable to want family to call before coming over?
No. Adults get to decide who enters their home and when, and wanting notice is one of the most ordinary boundaries there is. What varies is expectation: in families where dropping in has always been normal, the request will land as a change and needs gentleness rather than justification. If the pushback is persistent, and especially if it comes with guilt-laying or going around you to your partner, that pattern is usually about more than the door — and a couples counsellor or family therapist can be genuinely useful in unpicking it.











