The three cases where I repot anyway
First: the plant is genuinely strangled. Roots spiralling out of the drainage holes in a solid mat, water running straight through without wetting anything, the whole rootball lifting out of the pot like a dry brick. That plant is already struggling and will struggle more over winter. Move it.
Second: something has gone wrong in the soil. Fungus gnats in clouds, a sour smell, a crust of mineral build-up, or compost that has collapsed into dense black sludge after years in the same pot. Here you're not repotting for growth, you're replacing a bad environment, and waiting until March helps nobody.
Third: anything that has just come indoors from the balcony and arrived in a pot that's visibly failing — cracked terracotta, a nursery pot with no drainage, a hanging basket that dried out all summer. Fix the container now, while you're already handling the plant.
Everything else gets a far gentler intervention: top-dressing. Scrape off the top two or three centimetres of old compost, taking any mineral crust with it, and replace with fresh. It refreshes the surface, deals with a lot of gnat eggs, and leaves the root system entirely undisturbed.
How to do an autumn repot so the plant forgives you
Go up one pot size only. Two centimetres more diameter is plenty; the temptation to give a plant "room to grow" is how you end up with a reservoir of wet soil around a small rootball. Make sure there are drainage holes, and skip the layer of gravel at the bottom — it doesn't improve drainage, it just raises the wet zone.






