Bien Logo

Are the Truly Classic Grandmothers Disappearing? Will Anyone Still Roll Dough and Tell Stories?

Szabó Erzsébet5 min read
Share:
Are the Truly Classic Grandmothers Disappearing? Will Anyone Still Roll Dough and Tell Stories? — Family
In this article

Will Anyone Still Have a Grandmother Who Rolls Dough and Tells Stories?

I often think about my grandmothers. Neither of them is with me anymore, and maybe that’s why I feel more deeply how much they meant. I wasn’t one of the lucky ones who got to show their great-grandchild to their grandmother — I simply "ran out of time," being the youngest of the kids. Yet, my memories feel as fresh as if they happened yesterday.

I spent most summer breaks at one grandmother’s house; the other practically raised me. She was the one my mom turned to when I cried so much every morning at kindergarten that she couldn’t leave me there. I went to her every morning, and she patiently and lovingly guided me, played with me, recited rhymes, cooked — all while I barely noticed how much attention she gave me.

She Never Said, "I’m Too Busy Right Now"

Looking back as an adult, it’s almost unbelievable how present she always was. I can’t recall a single time she said she didn’t have time. Of course, she always had tasks — household chores, gardening, cooking, cleaning — but somehow she arranged her life so I never felt pushed aside. That house held a magical calm that felt natural then but now seems like an unreachable luxury.

Senior woman in apron making batter for cake. Little girl tasting cake batter standing in kitchen with grandmother.

My other grandmother was quite different — spirited, hardworking, sometimes a bit strict — but her love flowed just as strongly. In my mind, both were “classic” grandmothers: quietly bustling in aprons, always wanting to do something, never for themselves but for others. Only later did I learn how much pain, secrets, and sacrifice they carried — things we grandchildren never saw.

To us, they were safety itself: tangible love, warmth, and care.

I remember summers playing in the yard with cousins or neighborhood kids while my grandmother quietly watched from the background. Silently, without interrupting the fun, always ready to step in if needed. I remember the garden where we picked currants for syrup and balancing on bricks as I carried vegetable peels to the compost. And of course, the cocoa semolina dessert after dinner — because grandchildren could have anything. The scent of the house, the pantry shelves stacked to the ceiling, and the flour clouds when we tore up little dumplings… these tiny moments are etched into my childhood.

Will the Truly Classic Grandmothers Ever Disappear?

I find myself wondering more often: how long will those grandmothers who roll dough with their grandkids standing on little chairs and tell stories stay with us? The ones who garden just to fill their grandchildren’s baskets with fresh veggies, fruit, or homemade treats? I feel these grandmothers — the ones from our childhood — are slowly fading, making way for a new kind of grandmother.

Many of them still work after retirement because they need to. Others are rediscovering themselves: traveling, learning, joining communities, exercising, or staying connected with friends online.

They don’t picture old age in headscarves and aprons but fill their days with experiences, independence, and freedom. They’re not the “quietly watching from the background” grandmothers anymore but active, vibrant women who want to live fully — for their families and themselves.

And honestly, that’s a good thing. This change feels natural and necessary. The world’s pace has shifted, and women’s roles have evolved with it. Today’s grandmothers don’t want to lose themselves, and we should celebrate that choice. Still… we’ve experienced what it’s like when a grandmother tells stories from the past while teaching how to peel a boiled egg just right. Thinking that this might no longer happen brings a quiet, gentle sadness. We wish our children could feel that warm, all-encompassing presence we were lucky to have.

Maybe it hurts because our grandmothers were symbols of unconditional attention. They never rushed or hurried; being with them was uniquely peaceful. We try to pass that on to our kids — but the world’s rhythm has changed, and it’s harder to pause for a moment.

But Maybe the Answer Isn’t That “Things Were Better Back Then”

Maybe someone can still be a “truly classic” grandmother today — just in a different way. You can roll dough in the morning and listen to stories online with your grandchild in the afternoon. You can garden and show how the tomato seedlings grow over a video call. You can cook and share what it felt like to travel with retired friends for a weekend.

Perhaps today’s kids don’t need the same things we did. They might not seek safety sitting at the kitchen table but find it in a grandmother who’s brave, active, and curious about life. One who shows that aging isn’t a barrier but an opportunity. Because, after all, being a grandmother isn’t about knowing every recipe by heart — it’s about how you listen and love. And that love — in any form — will always be just as important.

Related reads

The last truly free summer: why today's kids will never know what we had — Family

The last truly free summer: why today's kids will never know what we had

Today's kids will never experience the wild, screen-free summers we had — and it's quietly taking away the one thing that made growing up feel free.

Szabó Erzsébet
Has the Magic of Easter Sprinkling Faded? A Story Through Two Little Girls’ Eyes — Family

Has the Magic of Easter Sprinkling Faded? A Story Through Two Little Girls’ Eyes

Easter used to be a special ritual that brought communities together. But as traditions evolve, fresh perspectives emerge.

Szabó Erzsébet
Easter Memories Everyone Knows — Which One’s Your Favorite? — Family

Easter Memories Everyone Knows — Which One’s Your Favorite?

Easter left a deep mark on me as a kid and remains one of my favorite holidays. It’s not just about traditions, but those moments that stay with us from childhood.

Farkas Margaréta
"My Mom and My Dad's New Girlfriend Got Into a Fistfight": Wedding Horror Stories You Won't Believe — Family

"My Mom and My Dad's New Girlfriend Got Into a Fistfight": Wedding Horror Stories You Won't Believe

Not every wedding becomes a beautiful memory. These real "big day" disasters are so chaotic you won't know whether to laugh, cringe, or hide under the table.

Szőke Angéla
My parents stayed together for us. I wish they hadn't. — Family

My parents stayed together for us. I wish they hadn't.

As a child, I was told my parents stayed together for our sake. As an adult, I've come to see that decision very differently — and more honestly.

Schuster Borka
Grandparents aren't free babysitters — and they have every right to say no to summer childcare — Family

Grandparents aren't free babysitters — and they have every right to say no to summer childcare

Every summer, parents quietly count on grandparents for childcare. But is that fair? A mom shares the mindset shift that changed everything for her family.

Szabó Erzsébet